J Streeter’s response leads Jews astray - www.jewishaz.com: Your Voice

J Streeter’s response leads Jews astray

MATTHEW KARLOVSKY, M.D. | Posted: Wednesday, June 10, 2015 10:00 am

I was impressed to read Larry Gellman’s opinion piece (“Baseless hatred of one Jew toward another over Israel,” Jewish News, May 29) attacking my article that called out J Street for half-truths about its support for Israel, because, apparently, my piece hit a nerve with him. He claimed that the points I made about J Street were “lies and slanderous rumors.” As Elvis Presley had famously said: “Truth is like the sun. You can shut it out for a time, but it ain’t goin’ away.” All the facts in my article were taken directly from J Street’s own national website and from the mouths of J Streeters and their supporters as documented in videos from official J Street events. His comments are the living embodiment of J Street doublespeak. His high-browed chastisement of my article as sinat chinam, creating hatred among Jews, is misplaced.

J Street goes to great lengths to overcompensate in their demonstration of being “pro-Israel.” The J Street websites self-congratulatory list of supporters is impressive. What’s disturbingly impressive is the enormous list of fellow Jews on J Street’s advisory council who themselves represent groups who openly attack Israel or give money or support to groups that attack Israel. Prominent Israeli politicians who are featured on J Street’s website include Labor Party Knesset members, members of the opposition, who  would, of course, oppose Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s security stance. As I said in my previous article, a two-state solution as promoted by Labor and J Street supporters is suicidal, since it places a terrorist PLO state on top of Jerusalem and near all major population centers, even dividing up Jerusalem. Moral high-mindedness about being critical of Israel as a way of being “pro-Israel” lends aid and comfort to an enemy that wishes to destroy Israel. Israel’s withdrawals from Gaza and Lebanon offer bloody proof that such moves decrease, rather than increase, Israel’s security.

Login required

We have used your information to see if you have a subscription with us, but did not find one.

Please click the button below to verify an existing account or to purchase a new subscription.

Need an account? Create one now.

You must login to view the full content on this page.