November 5, 1999/26 Cheshvan 5760, Vol. 52, No.10
Money talksEditorialJewish mega-donors are writing a communal meta-history, attempting to elevate the discourse of Jewish life. They are calling on Jews across the denominational spectrum to debate their differences respectfully, in the tradition of Hillel and Shammai, the renowned Talmudists who often disagreed.In an advertisement appearing in 35 Jewish newspapers across North America, including Jewish News this week, they are challenging the uncivilized, mean-spirited expression of distinct differences in Jewish orientation and opinion. Civility is in, they proclaim; irresponsible rhetoric is out. And they are promising to evaluate funding decisions, in part based on the civility level at which potential beneficiaries of their grants conduct their dialogue. Signers on the ad include the Andrea and Charles Bronfman Philanthropies, Judy and Michael Steinhardt Foundation, Ronald S. Lauder Foundation, Righteous Persons Foundation and Harry and Jeanette Weinberg Foundation. Among the local institutions benefiting from the largesse of these foundations are the Israel Center of Jewish Federation of Greater Phoenix, Kivel Campus of Care and Bureau of Jewish Education. This public affirmation of concern for mutual respect from American Jewry's most powerful and generous givers, many with egos to match their bank accounts, breaks new ground, as does their determination to make civility a criterion for future philanthropic grants. The endeavor of these benefactors to seek cohesiveness in the Jewish community is admirable. They have influenced the Jewish world by funding hundreds of creative endeavors that speak to how a multiplicity of voices can effect change. Now they are saying that while diversity is enriching and can inspire innovation, divisiveness, particularly when given voice in negative words and hateful epithets, can be destructive. They are showing us by their actions that money talks. We only hope this doesn't have a chilling effect on frank discussion of pertinent, important issues in the community. |
